2

I was curious why Islam uses the lunar calendar. The solar calendar seems more pragmatic because the same date falls in the same season every year. E.g. thanks to the solar calendar, it is easy to know that January 1, 1786 was winter in Copenhagen. It is much harder to derive the season in different geographic locations based on a lunar date.

The only advantage to the lunar calendar I can think of is to diversify the difficulty of the Ramadan fast, to make it easier in some years and harder in others. But are there any other benefits of and reasons why Islam uses it?

2

Pretty much every ancient and religious civilization used the lunar calendar, except those who worshiped the Sun. They were the only ones to use a solar calendar.

Even the original Christians used a lunar calendar until the Romans introduced polytheism into Christianity and changed the calculations.

So it's not really a matter of religion, it's what everyone did and Islam simply allowed it to continue in that manner. Allah didn't introduce a new way for Muslims to follow.

  • I don't think that's correct. Most calendars are either solar or lunisolar. In a lunisolar calendar, the position of the months are determined by the moon phases, but leap months are used so that dates also indicate the time of the solar year. This contrasts with the islamic calendar, which is purely lunar. Do you know any other example of a purely lunar calendar used by a major civilization? – Andreas Veithen Jan 25 '15 at 0:01
1

Thinking more about it, lunar calendar is more easy to follow than the solar calendar. People of all places/ways/styles/advances/etc can easily count days just by looking at varying shapes of the moon. As sun does not changes its appearance, dates cannot be counted just by looking at the sun and needs external astronomical means for this. This is one of the reason that all civilizations used lunar calendar from earlier times.

Actually, Islam also uses sun time keeping! Times of various salah is derived on the position of the sun, as this can be done easily.

Hence, both sun and moon are used for Islamic purpose -)

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.