Skip to main content
Islam

Return to Question

Question Protected by CommunityBot
Question Unprotected by UmH♦
Question Protected by UmH♦
added 38 characters in body; edited title
Source Link
Rebecca J. Stones
Rebecca J. Stones
  • 20.9k
  • 42
  • 167
  • 343

Why does Allah insists to create someone, whose fate is hell?

I'm really confused right now. Before he created our soul, He must know for sure, since He knows everything, thatwhether someone is going to go to paradise or hell when hethey die. And since there is no god above Allah, this knowledge must come from himself, thus he must plan it to be that way. Now it breaks 2However, this is inconsistent with two names of Allah,: The Most MercyfulMerciful one and The Most Fair one. 

How can He be the mercyfulmerciful one if He stil insists to create someone, whose fate is beeing tortured in hell forever if he already knew it would happen? And how can He be The Most Fair one if he decided Jack's fate is paradise but John's fate is hell  ? Yes

Yes we do have 'freewill''free will', but since He already planned that way, who knows that He controls our decision making as well  ? This

This question baffles me so much and threatsthreatens my faith immensely.

Why does Allah insists to create someone, whose fate is hell?

I'm really confused right now. Before he created our soul, He must know for sure, since He knows everything, that someone is going to go to paradise or hell when he die. And since there is no god above Allah, this knowledge must come from himself, thus he must plan it to be that way. Now it breaks 2 names of Allah, The Most Mercyful one and The Most Fair one. How can He be the mercyful one if He stil insists to create someone, whose fate is beeing tortured in hell forever if he already knew it ? And how can He be The Most Fair one if he decided Jack's fate is paradise but John's fate is hell  ? Yes we do have 'freewill', but since He already planned that way, who knows that He controls our decision making as well  ? This question baffles me so much and threats my faith immensely.

Why does Allah create someone whose fate is hell?

I'm really confused right now. Before he created our soul, He must know for sure, since He knows everything, whether someone is going to go to paradise or hell when they die. And since there is no god above Allah, this knowledge must come from himself, thus he must plan it to be that way. However, this is inconsistent with two names of Allah: The Most Merciful one and The Most Fair. 

How can He be the merciful one if He stil insists to create someone whose fate is beeing tortured in hell forever if he already knew it would happen? And how can He be The Most Fair if he decided Jack's fate is paradise but John's fate is hell?

Yes we do have 'free will', but since He already planned that way, who knows that He controls our decision making as well?

This question baffles me so much and threatens my faith immensely.

Tweeted twitter.com/StackIslam/status/748203991021006848
Source Link
maxime
maxime
  • 109
  • 1
  • 1
  • 3

Why does Allah insists to create someone, whose fate is hell?

I'm really confused right now. Before he created our soul, He must know for sure, since He knows everything, that someone is going to go to paradise or hell when he die. And since there is no god above Allah, this knowledge must come from himself, thus he must plan it to be that way. Now it breaks 2 names of Allah, The Most Mercyful one and The Most Fair one. How can He be the mercyful one if He stil insists to create someone, whose fate is beeing tortured in hell forever if he already knew it ? And how can He be The Most Fair one if he decided Jack's fate is paradise but John's fate is hell ? Yes we do have 'freewill', but since He already planned that way, who knows that He controls our decision making as well ? This question baffles me so much and threats my faith immensely.