Battle of Karbala
  • Member for 9 years, 7 months
  • Last seen this week
Is extra ibadah considered bidah?
1 votes

(This is a Shia view) Ibadah is two type. Wajib (obligatory) and Mustahab (liked). the example you said is not obligatory and is it is done without any belief that it is a rule in Islam there is no ...

View answer
Who was Allah's hojjat on Earth when Mohammad (saww) went to maraaj?
1 votes

When Prophet Muhammad (SAWW) went to Moraaj, 3 other Imams were present on earth. They are Imam Ali a.s. and Imam Hasan a.s. and Imam Hussain a.s. so the earth has not been empty form infallible Imam. ...

View answer
Is the joining of a non-Muslim in a jama'a salat allowed?
1 votes

I wonder why a non-Muslim would want to join Muslims in prayer. Maybe Muslims payed him to increase the reward of their prayer as Jama'at. According to Jafari Fiqh, a non-Muslim can join prayer of ...

View answer
Is it permissible to mix rulings from different madhabs?
1 votes

(Shia view) According to Shia scholars No and a Muslim should personally without any personal prefer do enough research and find highest knowledgeable scholar and follow his different Fitwa. Usually ...

View answer
Can we seek interpretation of dreams?
Accepted answer
1 votes

According to Hadith dreams are categorized in 3 different types and Only one type of dreams have interpretations and other two are false dreams from Satan or useless dreams. The useless dreams are ...

View answer
What is the concept of sects in Islam?
1 votes

Sect is made by difference in basic beliefs (not Fiqh or rulings). Any sect claims to have correct beliefs and correct understanding and interpretation and hadith collections of Islam. The main belief ...

View answer
Jannah, it's levels and the extent to which wishes shall be fulfilled
1 votes

will there be levels in jannah? Yes, According to some verses like the one quoted below, Paradise does have different levels: لَّا يَسْتَوِي الْقَاعِدُونَ مِنَ الْمُؤْمِنِينَ غَيْرُ‌ أُولِي ...

View answer
What to do with paper after writing the name of Allah?
1 votes

According to Fiqh of Shia Islam the name of Allah should be respected always and burning them is disrespect and Haram. They can be buried in earth or left in rivers or hided by thick black pen or ...

View answer
Ruling on covering the tooth with gold or silver?
1 votes

According to Fiqh of Shia Islam if gold is used to cover tooth for purpose of beauty it is Haram for men (but permitted for women) in any condition (in prayer or not prayer, in Hajj or not Hajj). Only ...

View answer
What are the details of different types of Salat?
Accepted answer
1 votes

Farz and Wajib are the same and means obligatory. Sunnat and Nafil are the same and means recommended but not obligatory. a slight difference is Sunnat is mostly used for practices done by the ...

View answer
Islamic view on getting married if you have no time/energy
1 votes

According to Fiqh of Shia Islam Marriage is basically recommended and not obligatory provided not marrying does not cause any sin (for example masturbation). But if not marrying cause any sin it ...

View answer
All bidah are haram or not?
1 votes

(This is a Shia view) No. there are two type of Bidah. Accepted and Haram. Accepted is what does not change any rule in Islam. Like innovations related to technology which have nothing to do with ...

View answer
What is the reasoning behind argument that saying I give you divorce 3 times doesn't count as at all?
1 votes

The reasoning is that if no return (having husband-wife relations) happens no new divorce is possible. New relation is needed to new divorce be counted. Divorce without any prior intimate relation is ...

View answer
Can you call on and worship Allah without knowing His name?
1 votes

Firstly according to Islam universe is a creation of God among thousands of other universes and worshiping it is considered Shirk (polytheism). But for who do not know the truth and do not know Islam, ...

View answer
Does the “three times” count still apply if we use “detergent”?
1 votes

According to Fiqh of Shia Islam Yes, the “three times” count still apply if we use “detergent”. But “three times” is only for situation the water used is Under-Kurr water. After removal of Najasat ...

View answer
What is a Hadith?
1 votes

Hadith literally means saying. And refers to sayings of Prophet narrated by people. After Prophet SAWW there was bans on narration and writings of hadith and first hadith collections were by Bukhari ...

View answer
What is the difference between a Sunni and a Shiite Mosque?
1 votes

Shia pray with open hands and Sunni pray with closed hands. But Shia and Sunni may pray at mosque of each other. In fact mosque is not for Shia or Sunni. It depends on local population of Shia or ...

View answer
Why was Quran not compiled at the time of the Prophet?
1 votes

According to Shia Quran was compiled at life of prophet by Imam Ali as. He came to home of prophet every night and said Salam. If heard reply entered and if not backed. At nights prophet said the ...

View answer
What are Satanic verses?
1 votes

By definition a Satanic verse is a verse induced to mind of prophet by Satan that prophet think this is a revealed verse from God. But in real life of prophet such think did not happened because God ...

View answer
Status of a Sayyad/Syed/Sayyid (a descendant from the family of the Holy Prophet [pbuh])?
1 votes

According to Jafari Fiqh: Sayyed can receive Sadaqah only from Sayyed. Also only Wajib Sadaqah like Zikat Fitrah and Zikat of property and Khums are banned to Sayyids. And they can receive Mustahab ...

View answer
Is it permissible for Muslim men/women to modify or set their eye brows?
Accepted answer
1 votes

(This answer is based on view and fatwa of current Maraji) According to different hadith about beauty of woman and duties of woman for her husband totally (without considering some specific hadith ...

View answer
Getting rid of ants and insect Islamic way?
1 votes

Generally the fitwa of Shia scholars is that if they are harmful they can be killed but if not harmful you are not allowed to kill. There are chemicals for killing them if they are harming. But ...

View answer
How tall was Prophet Adam (PBUH)?
1 votes

There are two branches of thought regarding the hadith of Adam's height (i.e. "Allah created Adam, making him 60 cubits tall."); while some scholars consider it wholly authentic, other scholars (...

View answer
Inquiry about source of income, haram or halal
1 votes

This is a form of marketing. Marketing is not basically Haram but there is recommended in Islam that treating with fairness (انصاف) with customers in business. And also it is Mustahab if an owner of a ...

View answer
How many wives did Hazrat Hassan (R.A) had?
Accepted answer
1 votes

The number of his wives is not recorded in history, and Shia scholars do not speculate about this number. At least the scholars I asked said this is not recorded in history. But in different books, ...

View answer
"About some things He was silent-out of compassion for you, not forgetfulness, so seek not after them" - What things?
1 votes

They are anything have no rule in Islam. Your hadith says "so seek not after them" and this question seems is seeking after them. They are permitted and so better we do not seek them. As an example: ...

View answer
Where was Muhammad al-Baqir(as) during the Battle of Karbala and what followed?
Accepted answer
1 votes

At Battle of Karbala he was a small child and was with Caravan of Imam Hussain a.s. and he was inside the tent with the women and other children. Women especially Sayyedah Zeinab a.s. (the sister of ...

View answer
What is the Islamic view of seeking blessings from prophet's hairs?
1 votes

(This Answer is according to view of Shia scholars) Is there any basis for seeking Barakah (blessings) from Prophet's hair? By referring to the last chapter of Sahih Bukhari about jihad and also the ...

View answer
How to resolve a difference of opinion among scholars?
1 votes

Wa Alaykum Assalam, This answer is based on Shia Islam view It is obvious every human is free to accept or not any opinion. But important is to discover which opinion is accepted by real Islam of ...

View answer
Does the Holy Spirit also exist in Islam?
1 votes

The holy sprite (روح القدس) is mentioned in 4 verses of Quran. For example: And We did certainly give Moses the Torah and followed up after him with messengers. And We gave Jesus, the son of Mary,...

View answer
1
6
7
8 9 10