Hot answers tagged

2

I see no contradiction here. The first hadith was narrated by ibn Umar, with no indication that Umar or Abu Bakr were even present to hear it. The second hadith being discussed is narrated by multiple narrators, in meaning if not verbatim. The most obvious explanation is that these are simply two different statements said at two different times to two ...


Only top voted, non community-wiki answers of a minimum length are eligible