8
votes
Accepted
what is the Chain of Sahih Bukhari from Imam Bukhari to us?
Your question actually is related to:
Original Copies of Muhammad al-Bukhari's Books?
Can any hadith truly be called sahih anymore?
The first question is looking for an original manuscript of ...
- 44.6k
6
votes
Accepted
Is Musnad Ahmed a book of Sahih Ahaadith?
Musnad al-Imam Ahmad is not a sahih book, as Imam Ahmad never claimed in his book to quote only sahih narrations, rather than collecting the biggest amount of sunnah which is used as evidence by ...
- 44.6k
6
votes
Why is Musnad Ahmad not like other Sahih Books?
The answer is simple as the title says it is a musnad المسند which is classified by the sanad the first narrator (the narrator -Sahabi()- on whom's authority a hadith was transmitted).
A distinction ...
- 44.6k
5
votes
Accepted
Do modern Hanafi scholars still rely on mash'hur ahadith?
The well-known sunnah (al-sunnah al-mashhūra, Arabic: السنة المشهورة) continues to be used till today by Hanafi scholars to:
establish rulings of the Hanafi jurisprudence,
do tafsir of the Qur'an,
...
- 14.6k
5
votes
Did Imam Ash-Shafei reject some hadith?
I am not sure where this opinion is coming from, and I do not claim that it never existed, but I have not come across it. On the contrary, Ahmad ibn 'Abdul-Wahhāb Ash-Shanqīti in his book Khabar al-...
- 14.6k
5
votes
Accepted
Authenticity of Kanz al-Ummal?
Anyone who have basic knowledge of hadees science knows that their are many types of collections of ahadees from which sahih is the type in which the collector/author tries his best to make sure that ...
- 3,033
5
votes
Accepted
Did Imam Malik describe the hadith sciences as "this science is a religion"?
The description of knowledge of hadith as quoted in your question predates Imam Mālik; it goes back to an athar by Ibn Sirīn:
حدثنا محمد بن علي، حدثنا النضر بن عون، عن ابن سيرين قال: هذا الحديث دين،...
- 14.6k
5
votes
Did Imam Malik describe the hadith sciences as "this science is a religion"?
Ibn Sirin's quote
Of course the athar of ibn Sireen (Sirin) محمد بن سيرين which you may find quoted with a full narrator chain is widely known for a large audience (and maybe this is the source of ...
- 44.6k
5
votes
Accepted
What exactly is tadlees?
Disclaimer. Since this question is three questions in one (1. what is tadlīs and its types, 2. what is the ruling of a hadith with tadlīs, and 3. what is the ruling of a person who practiced tadlīs), ...
- 14.6k
5
votes
Accepted
Is there an explanation how abu Hurairah managed to narrate more than 5K hadith?
Abu Hurairah (RA)'s large amount of narrations are due to multiple reasons working together. We have to also keep in mind the following statement by Abdullah ibn Umar (RA), the second highest narrator,...
- 9,403
5
votes
Is being a sunni or having sunni toughts a reason not to be reliable as a hadith narrator (shi'a hadith)?
Interesting question.
I'm not a hadith scholar and I am new to this field. This is what I've read so far.
There are a number of hadith categories in Twelver Shia hadith science with respect to the ...
- 3,901
5
votes
Is the hadith with the poem recited by Abbas after Tabuk authentic?
A first analysis of the sources
You've done a huge work by gathering all these different sources!
Here a short first feedback:
As you mentioned the 5th line seemingly only appears in the book of as-...
- 44.6k
4
votes
Accepted
What was the earliest Hadith Book / Collection to be recorded?
The point is what do you define as a hadith book or hadith collection?
Records of hadith in the early days of Islam
As hadith was in first place (the same as Quran) memorized and spread through oral ...
- 44.6k
4
votes
Accepted
Is al Hakims Hadith collection Al Mustadrak reliable?
Abu Abd-Allah Muhammad ibn Abd-Allah Al-Hakim from Nishapur was a hadith scholar and hafidh from the 4th century he was a student of ad-Daraqutni (whom nevertheless narrated some ahadith from him) and ...
- 44.6k
4
votes
Accepted
Can you explain the status of mursal hadith?
The short answer is it depends, but generally speaking not authentic.
Definition
The definition of a hadith mursal is that the tābi'i (Arabic: التابعى), which is the generation after the companions ...
- 14.6k
4
votes
Why is Abu Huraira considered unreliable by Shia fiqh?
[Not being a Shia myself, if someone sees a mistake here please edit and rectify it].
The Jafaris\Imamis do not consider Abu Hurairah to be a reliable narrator, because they have a narration from Imam ...
- 25k
4
votes
Accepted
How scientific are Hadith sciences?
In a nutshell
... the "science" lies in the systematic nature of determining the veracity of a narration attributed to the Prophet Muhammad ﷺ.
The scientific nature of 'Uloom-ul-Hadeeth lies in the ...
- 1,021
4
votes
Accepted
Which scholars deny hadith being mutawātir?
I will make some assumptions first prior to answering, since otherwise the answer would be excessively long:
By "which scholars", I am assuming you are referring to hadith scholars only.
By "denied ...
- 14.6k
4
votes
Accepted
Wrong explanation about science by Prophet Muhammad
Firstly, where is the "wrong explanation about science"? You are assuming that the Prophet said that no pollination at all is better, however the Prophet is only talking about human assisted ...
- 96
4
votes
Accepted
refrence of hadith telling evil eye overtakes qaddar?
About Your First Question:
The exact hadeeth wording and its reference:
Muslim, Ahmad, and al-Tirmidhi narrated from Ibn ‘Abbas that the Prophet (peace and blessings of Allah be upon him) said:
“...
- 516
3
votes
How can seemingly contradictory ahadith still be classified as sahih?
All perfect praise be to Allah
Firstly, i should admit, i am not even a student of hadees, but still i will share what i know. Feel free to correct me where i am wrong.
As in your question you have ...
- 3,033
3
votes
How many ahad hadith are there in Sahih Bukhari?
I found an upper bound for the amount of ahad hadiths of both sahihs in a statement of ibn Hajjar al-'Asqalani (in his book called al-Madkhal fi osol al-Hadith المدخل في أصول الحديث) saying it is ...
- 44.6k
3
votes
Can a strong hadith be wrong? If so, what do I do?
Scholars accept the possibility of a hadith being 'wrong' based on its matn (the content reported). Al-Sakhawi (d 1497) quotes Abu'l-Faraj ibn al-Jawzi (d.1200) in Fath al-Mugeeth:
وكل حديث رأيته ...
- 1,768
3
votes
What is the meaning of hadith grading "Sahih in Chain"?
A sahih hadith refers only to the chain of narration. So when you see the phrase "hadith sahih", it means that:
The chain is complete from its start at the Prophet to its end (ما اتصل سنده من مبدأه ...
- 14.6k
3
votes
Why is Abu Huraira considered unreliable by Shia fiqh?
بسم الله الرحمن الرحیم
In order to elucidate the issue, of note, there can be diverse reasons/evidences for rejecting him (and in order to prove everyone, there need long discussion and documents... ...
3
votes
Accepted
Are ahadith generally considered to be paraphrased?
They are not suppose to be. But they will be to some extent. Why? Have you ever played the telephone game? Also they didn't have a computer that would underline grammatical mistakes for them. ...
- 2,620
3
votes
On what basis are the Sahaba considered trustworthy narrators of Hadeeth?
The Sahaba (who comprise of the Muhajirun and Ansar) are deemed trustworthy for many reasons:
Allah attests to their truthfulness and success
لِلْفُقَرَاء الْمُهَاجِرِينَ الَّذِينَ أُخْرِجُوا مِن ...
- 1,021
3
votes
What is the authenticity of hadith describing people of paradise with white complexion and curly hair?
The website you mentioned in your question is discussing a different topic altogether: Whether Al-Hasan and Al-Hussain are the masters of the youth in Paradise. The website is a Shi'a website, but ...
- 14.6k
3
votes
What is the minimum amount of narrations needed in order for a hadith to be classed as mutawatir according to the different scholars?
Basically any opinion quoting a minimum amount has no backup... but a logical approach would say it needs at least 4 as else the hadith would be considered as a kind of ahaad (well strictly speaking ...
- 44.6k
Only top scored, non community-wiki answers of a minimum length are eligible