Sin is desirable by definition otherwise people wouldn't have fallen for it! But religion tells us to resist the desire because sin is in reality harmful.
It is not difficult for us to see how some desirable things can be harmful. Junk food can be very delicious but they are bad for health. Drinking gives a lot of joy but it harms the brain and compromises ...
Relevant verse from which we can draw an analogy:
وقد نزل عليكم في الكتاب أن إذا سمعتم آيات الله يكفر بها ويستهزأ بها فلا تقعدوا معهم حتى يخوضوا في حديث غيره إنكم إذا مثلهم إن الله جامع المنافقين والكافرين في جهنم جميعا (And it has already come down to you in the Book that when you hear the verses of Allah [recited], they are denied [by them] and ...
As I understand your question, you are asking whether wrong thoughts/negative feelings (such as jealousy, anger, hate etc) are caused only by sinful actions.
The answer in my humble opinion is no. Firstly, only Allah (SWT) knows the true inner thoughts of a person and what one may perceive as a bad thought ("inner sin") may turn out to be a positive thing. ...
It can be caused by both sins and wrongful thoughts as you mentioned. Generally there are three factors that contribute to our inner state:
Physiological/neurological traits and conditions*
Thoughts including our worldview and self-image
It is proven in neuroscience that brain conditions influence our moral attitude towards life and others in ...
I will try to answer your question by breaking it into smaller parts.
Can you provide a reference to the below statement of yours from the Quran or Sahih Hadiths:
I know that in the day of judgment those that didn't have any
possibility to learn Islam will have a parallel world that will last
50 thousand years created for them and will be tested by ...
He is a child a child doesn't know right and wrong ,he may understand it on the surface but doesn't realize it internally till puberty.He has to make mistakes so he can learn .Its important not to interfere in his learning and natural development.
Let me answer your question on two parts:
Islam is as our prophet Muhammad explained
" Who is Muslim?
A Muslim is whom people are safe from his tongue and his hands".
Good deeds are written by angels, but the bad ones is not written unless you know it is bad.
In your example you said
What about those that were atheistic and ...