It is required in Islam to pay the zakat and other obligations towards the leader of the Muslims, for this a registry of Muslims is essential was such a registry maintained by the Muslims of the time? and does it help to have a global database of Muslims around the world for better management and utilization of Muslim resources?


There is a major Shia Islamic sect which makes it compulsory to have a unique ID cards for its adherents and I see them using it to profile its adherents and manage the human resources in an efficient way. All their religious activities, payments etc are logged in a global database. Is this a correct thing to do?


That would be against the basic principle of Islam-- no one else could tell what one believes in. Even zakat-- which has a society aspect is totally voluntary, on one's own judgement. I don't think anyone should be asked to "declare" his/her religion. It should remain between the self and the God.

  • Ofcourse we judge by what is visible and this applied to all who call themselves Muslims and not those who wont.
    – Islam
    Jun 17 '13 at 5:18
  • There can be and not hard to gather has been those pretending to believe. Zakat is one way. You can judge giving away to others. what for he did is not upon you.
    – ashley
    Jun 17 '13 at 7:00
  • Zakat is not my motivation behind the question nor is personal relationship with God, I am just exploring the efficiency of a Database that can help the Muslims
    – Islam
    Jun 17 '13 at 7:03
  • Your db wouldn't necessarily be accurate. Not all muslims would be willing to talk about their beliefs. I personally dislike the idea-- a step to categorizing people on their beliefs wouldn`t be any different.
    – ashley
    Jun 17 '13 at 7:36

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .