0

I had asked this question before but I couldn't able to provide the actual reference that's why I'm posting the question again if someone can explain please respond. So the question was in the book mizan al-etidel in the Muslim library al-makta Shamela it's something like the finger of the prophet Muhammad (saw) shrink or changed and the belly also start growing is it true?

It is contradicting the hadeeth in sunan ibn majah (1636).

enter image description here

6
  • 1
    Well this was already linked to an answer before you deleted your former question
    – Medi1Saif
    Oct 31 '21 at 15:52
  • Yes I know but I didn't provide the right refrence ...I'm sorry for that Oct 31 '21 at 16:16
  • It's is from a different book ....is it the same book or narration you provided in previous question and if the answer is same than I'm sorry because I thought this has different narration .... And translation I have provided in the above image is also different.... please correct me if I'm wrong Oct 31 '21 at 16:22
  • You didn't provide any reference here it is a text without a source which says that 'Abdulamajeed made a fatwa in which he ordered or adviced Harun ar-Rashid to kill Waki'a for spreading such a narrative. And none of both strictly speaking is a hadith as such things couldn't be reported from a person who is dead (the prophet) it is rather an athar however there's no chain of transmission of the version of Waki'a while the others have one.
    – Medi1Saif
    Oct 31 '21 at 17:22
  • Jazakallah brother Oct 31 '21 at 18:01
0

The relevant part of the hadith which you have asked about is as follows:

أن رسول الله (صلى الله عليه وسلم) لما مات لم يدفن حتى ربا بطنه وانثنت خنصرا

When the Messenger of Allah ﷺ died he was not buried until his belly was swollen and his fingers were bent

Tareekh Dimashq Ibn 'Asaakir

This is not recorded in any hadith collection, rather it is recorded in books of history under the trial of Wakee‘ ibn al-Jarraah. The incident goes that Wakee' recounted this hadith in Mecca and the people interpreted that he was trying to insult of the Prophet ﷺ and so wanted to kill and crucify him. Wakee was imprisoned and some scholars gave a fatwa for his execution, however he was eventually spared. Scholars have generally considered this narration as a mistake on his part without having an intention of disrespecting the Prophet ﷺ.

This hadith is not authentic.

  1. Its chain of transmission is broken. It is narrated by Abdullah al-Bahi (عبد الله البهي), who is a Tabi and not a Sahabi. This means that he was not alive during the lifetime of the prophet and hence was not a witness to his death and burial. If he heard of this incident from someone else, then he does not mention from whom he heard it.

  2. The hadith was considered unheard of and blasphemous by various scholars, hence it is probable that it was formed from a delusion or misunderstanding of one of the transmitters.

  3. It contradicts authentic ahadith that the body of the prophet was in a good and clean state:

    طبت حيا وميتا

    you are good in life and in death

    Bukhari

    عن علي رضي الله عنه قال: غسلت رسول الله صلى الله عليه وسلم فجعلت أنظر ما يكون من الميت فلم أر شيئا، وكان طيبا حيا وميتا

    Ali ibn Abi Talib said: I gave the funeral bath to the Messenger of Allah and looked for that which is usually looked for on the deceased but found nothing. For he was pure in death as he was pure in life.

    Sunan al-Kubra Bayhaqi - Classed as Sahih by al-Albani, Nawawi, Hakim etc.

Ref: islamqa and islamweb

1
  • Jazakallah.... It was really helpful Oct 31 '21 at 20:04

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .