Islam Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for Muslims, experts in Islam, and those interested in learning more about Islam. It only takes a minute to sign up.
Sign up to join this community
Sunni islam accepts a number of madhahib, each seen as co-valid (despite differences of opinion, other schools are not considered as sinful or transgressing).
There are also various schools of 'aqidah, differing on creed rather than laws. Are such schools considered co-valid among Sunnis the same way that schools of fiqh are? Can one pick and choose thus, as one can choose a madh'hab?
There is no room for being accommodative of differences in the main matters of creed. Creed is not something that is derived or interpreted - it is knowledge of the unseen that is given to us by Allah and His Messenger. There are usul (trunk) and furu` (branches). In some secondary matters (branches) where there isn't a consensus or contradictory reports, a difference of opinion is unavoidable. However in the core matters, this is not acceptable.
For the most part, the Sunni schools of `aqidah agree on the majority of the core (tawheed, qada, qadr, etc), with disagreements on some issues. These differences are not sufficient on any side to declare the other sides as being outside the fold of Islam - aspects of their creed are however labeled incorrect/misguided.
Both the Maturidis and the Asharis view each other as valid but different. However, both schools view the Wahhabi/Salafi school as incorrect. The Wahhabi/Salafi school, on the other hand, views both of them as deviant. So the answer depends on which school you ask.
