0

This dua is to be recited after adhaan

Allahumma rabba hadhihi-d-da’awati-t-tammati wa-s-Salati-l-qa’imati, ati Muhammadan il-wasilata wa-l-fadilata (wa-d-darajata-r-rafi’ati) wa-b‘ath-hu maqamam mahmudan illadhi wa‘adtahu

Reference : Sahih al-Bukhari 614

But almost everyone adds this extra verse when reciting that is not part of the dua.

(innaka la tukhliful mi’ad)

I heard that this is an innovation, since it's not part of the dua. Like some say sadaqallahul azim after reciting Quran.

So is saying (innaka la tukhliful mi’ad) with that dua an innovation?

2
  • From which perspective are you speaking? It certainly is not bid'ah as Allah Himself used this expression in a du'a in qur'an in surat Aal-'Imraan.
    – Medi1Saif
    Jan 16, 2021 at 16:13
  • Searching on google it addressed here and here that it is an uncommon addition present in the Sunan of Bayhaqi. Also as @Medi1Saif said the phrase itself is in the Quran in 3:194.
    – UmH
    Jan 17, 2021 at 6:16

1 Answer 1

0

إِنَّكَ لَا تُخلِفُ المِيعِاد

This addition was weakened by al-Albani, Shu'aib al-Arna'ut, Abdullah as-Sa'd, Mustafa al-Adwi, al-Harith al-Hasani and Sulayman al-Alwan.

Muhammad bin 'Awf Al-Ta'i was alone in narrating this addition. The hadith was narrated by (al-Alwan said, "more than 11 narrators".) senior memorizers of ahadith including Ahmad bin Hanbal, Ibn Ali al-Madini, Bukhari and others, without the addition of "innaka la tukhliful mi'aad". So this addition is shadh (anomalous), not authentic.

3
  • The addition of a trustworthy narrator isn't always authentic, you actually have to look into it if it's authentic or not. The later scholars were very lenient in this matter so they generally authenticated additions. So no attention should be paid to those who came later and authenticated this hadith. Jul 5, 2023 at 17:18
  • سؤال(2) هل يوجد فرق بين زيادة الثقة وتفرد الثقة؟ زيادة الثقة هي ما يرويه الثقة زيادة على غيره من الثقات، وهذه الزيادة هي تفرد من هذا الثقة زادها على من شاركه في رواية الحديث نفسه عن الشيخ، وهذه الزيادة لا تقبل مطلقًا ولا تُرَدّ مطلقًا، وإنما نتبع في ذلك القرائن، فقد تقبل وقد ترد، وأما تفرد الثقة إن كان القصد هو ما يتفرد به عمن شاركه في الرواية عن شيخه؛ فهي نفسها زيادة الثقة، وإن كان المقصود تفرد الثقة بحديث ما؛ فإن كان ممن يُحتمل تفرده فيقبل حديثه وإلا فلا. #المائة_الأولى_من_الأَجوبة_الحايكية_على_الأسئلة الحديثية Jul 5, 2023 at 17:27
  • Forgot to mention, al-Hasanî said that the entire hadīth is defective. Listen to his telegram voice note for more details. Wallahu alam. Jul 6, 2023 at 20:46

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .