2

The Muslims are supposed to do good things in life expecting they will get it paid back as a good life after death. But if atheists are doing something, they are purely doing it for the love of people, isn't it?

So whatever Muslims do, under those deeds are lying our selfishness to get a better life after death.

Can we do good deeds saying:

"God you don't have to count this thing, I am doing only for the love of people, care, humanity, etc." ?

Am I right?

  • No, because eventually people will neglect you in the end. When it comes to heaven and hell, there is selfishness, since they both are eternal – abdul Nov 9 at 21:32
  • The issue of altruism is valid in this world, but not in the day of judgement, because no soul (and I mean, NO SOUL) will sacrifice themselves for another one in order for the former to be thrown into the hell fire forever. This thing, moreover, motivates Muslims to do good actions since they are given reward, and if it was not that way, you would find zero Muslims helpful in the first place. So it might seem selfish to you, but not to Allah – abdul Nov 9 at 21:36
2

Bismillah, this is my first post in this SE network.

As Muslims, we are supposed to do everything with intention only for Allah. In that way, everything that we do can be given a reward (thawaab). Indeed, it is mainly for our own good both in this world and hereafter, but we also do good things to others (including non-muslims) because Allah and His messenger ask us to do so. Also, doing good things to others also means that we do it because we love them. Take this example: if we prevent a muslim from doing sin, that's actually because we love him and we don't want him to be punished in the hereafter.

That's actually how we as an individual can spread the beauty of Islam.

Can we do good deeds saying

god, god you don't have to count this, this thing I am doing only for the love of people, care, humanity, etc,..?

The answer is no. We as muslim will and will not do anything only for Allah. And of course those that you mentioned (for the love of people, etc.) will follow.

Wallahu alam - only Allah knows best

0

But if an atheist is doing something, He is purely doing it for the love of people, Isn't it?

There is an debate in philosophy (Psychological egoism) that all humans are inherently selfish beings. All of their behavior is in their self-interest and motivated by their instinct of self-preservation. Some of them may be deluded into believing that they are being altruistic, however subconsciously even their actions are motivated by expectation of reward and fear of punishment.

An atheist may not expect reward from God in the hereafter, but he may anticipate some form of reward in this life from other people. Suppose that he seemingly selflessly gives charity to a homeless beggar. However rewards that he could actually be craving are:

  • Reciprocity. He might perceive some direct or indirect benefit from his act at a later time. The beggar himself may be in a position to help in a different situation; or the aim might be to propagate the value of generosity in society which could at some point be useful to him and his children etc. Perhaps it is this expectation of recompense that the atheist is seeking?

  • Gratitude, praise and recognition by the people. The person he helps will be thankful to him, the society will appreciate and glorify him. All of these will make the atheist feel good about himself. Perhaps if it is this feeling of pleasure - the high caused by release of hormones - that the atheist is seeking?

So, is his act really for the love of people, care, humanity? Or does he have something to gain from it? If he has something to gain or lose, then it is suspect whether his motivation is truly selfless. And his claim of having some sort of moral superiority over a believer is debatable.

Can we do good deeds saying god, god you don't have to count this, this thing I am doing only for the love of people, care, humanity, etc,..?

As Muslim you should do good deeds for pleasure of Allah and hoping for reward from Him.

And whoever desires the reward of this world - We will give him thereof; and whoever desires the reward of the Hereafter - We will give him thereof. And we will reward the grateful. - Aale Imran 145

Those who enjoin charity or that which is right or conciliation between people. And whoever does that seeking means to the approval of Allah - then We are going to give him a great reward. - An-Nisa 114

Can you afford to relinquish your reward and tell God "you don't have to count this, this thing I am doing only for the love of people" you may find that out when the time of accounting comes.

That Day shall a man flee from his brother,
And from his mother and his father,
And from his wife and his children.
Every man, that Day, will have enough to make him careless of others.
- Abasa 34 to 37

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.