0

I know that in Islam it is haram to masturbate, even in case a man cannot marry and in case one cannot marry than he has to resort into fasting, for it diminishes sexual desire. But what if the man in question has huge sexual desire, cannot marry in any way whatsoever and he has DIABETES (he cannot fast because of that)???

Strain: Sunni

Creed: Athari

Manhaj: Salafi

Madhab/jurisprudence followed: generally none , although I'd personally deem the Hanbali one as the best because it was the madhab of Imam al Bukhari, Ibn Taymiyyah and Muhammad ibn Abd al Wahhab.

P.S: I'm not justifying masturbation forcibly in this case, but I want to know whether the "daroorat" issue applies here

P.P.S advice to those who engage in it. From my experience, I can tell you that, when I was being accustomed to masturbate thrice a day, it rendered me just numb mentally and psychologically, not making me focus on things properly and moreover it made me forget thinks very quickly and often. It harms more mentally than physically, even though there's a great extent in both aspects. Don't masturbate. Even zina, which is a bigger fa7sha, is physically healthier than masturbation because it can be just anatomically and physically similar to sex between married man and his wife (NOTE: I'm NOT condoning zina in any way shape or form, you'll get what I mean if you're mind bearing) (the physical outcome from sexual intercourse between two healthy people of opposite gender and the marriage counterpart of the latter would be the same)

  • The verdict for masturbation doesn't change just because of the madhhab or circumstances. The majority considers it haram. Ibn Tayymiyah considers it haram or makroh as it is much better than committing zina. You may find a helpful response in Is masturbation permissible for a man during an extended period of unmarried life?. None of the named scholars would consider himself hanbali. as all of them had an own madhhab which differs from the hanbali school of fiqh. – Medi1Saif Oct 31 '19 at 6:42
  • I mentioned another condition which makes the scenario more peculiar, the person involved cannot fast because he is diabetic. – abdul Oct 31 '19 at 10:01
  • Yes but many Muslims fast even if having diabetes or heart issues. And if you masturbate you usually do it in secret and as long as it doesn't become a habit one can repent from it why should we pretend that we are free from sins? Allah created as and He knows we are sinners and He expects from us to repent. As long as there is difference of opinion on a matter there are halal options (like sports) and repentance is the most important sign of faith! – Medi1Saif Oct 31 '19 at 12:01
  • As far as I know diabetic people aren't able to fast (I didn't mean it is forbidden for them while using "cannot", but that they aren't able to). – abdul Oct 31 '19 at 12:40
  • 3

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.