The scholars of Islam now days study Islam 16 hours a day. They read so many books that they seem to have a reservoir of brain. They read so many tafsirs, fiqh, akide and study in details even a single word from the Quran. They study all that religious experience of 14 centuries. They have an entire science for studying even one branch of islam like hadith science, fiqh science etj... Every tag in islam stack exchange is a science. My question is: Why then do we say that the most knowledgeable people are Abu Bakr,then Omar,then those closer to him?? Then the tabiine, then the first three good generations.

  • Unfortunately, many of the 'scholars' of today do not practice what they preach. This differentiates the first 3 generations from them. Many people in Arabia converted by just observing the behavior of the Prophet & the Sahaba, Tabain & Tabe Tabain. Very few of today's scholars can truthfully claim to be on par with them.
    – Ahmed
    Jul 15, 2019 at 5:08
  • 1
    Who says that the first 3 generations are the most knowledgeable? Could you provide any evidence or source for that?
    – Medi1Saif
    Jul 17, 2019 at 6:48

1 Answer 1


It is because the source of the knowledge is the Prophet. The companions observed and learned from the prophet directly for several decades and were intimately familiar with the context of the revelation of the Quraan and Quraanic Arabic was their mother tongue in which they were experts. Only a fraction of their knowledge is preserved and passed onto modern scholars. Even from the generation of the Tabieen, there are those who it is said that they had memorised more ahadith than the total number of ahadith that are present today in books all together.

  • If somebody -in the early days- memorized more hadith than we have present today that doesn't necessarily means that there are many ahadith missing today. It means they have narrated more versions of ahadith as each narrator chain + hadith content counts as one hadith. Al-Hafidh ibn Hajar for example often points at differences in the narrations of Students of imam al-Bukhari of the same hadith.
    – Medi1Saif
    Jul 17, 2019 at 6:53

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .