1

Abu Dharr from the tribe of Bani Ghifar was a highwayman. He was also one of the earliest reverts to Islam. Did the Prophet (pbuh) allow him to stay as a highwayman or was the Prophet (pbuh) not aware of Abu Dharr's livelihood?

"Who are thy people?" said the Prophet, and at the man's answer he looked him up and down in amazement and said: "Verily God guideth whom He will." [...] Meantime he continued his calling as highwayman, with special attention to the caravans of Quraysh.

  • Note that raiding the caravans of the Quraysh would not be stealing, as they were Harbi. – UmH May 12 at 6:40
  • @UmH The passage in the book about Abu Dharr explicitly states that his tribe are known robbers. If you'd like, I can quote the passage. – Shadi May 12 at 7:41
1

The Prophet (ﷺ) told Muslims not to plunder.

It's true that the tribe of Ghifar were previously known raiders however in the end they embraced Islam and were pardoned by Allah (ﷻ). After repentance, people are not held to their 'old' reputation nor can we make assumptions about them based on their old ways. They start with a clean new reputation.

With Abu Dharr (RA) after conversion, he is mostly described in biography books as being involved with Da'wah, speaking truth, being at the Prophet's service and close company for seeking knowledge and his asceticism (withdrawing from the world).

This is the first I'm hearing of "continued raids". And I'm not quite sure of the accuracy of the account because within that same section it says Abu Dharr easily found the Prophet ("without difficulty he found his way to the Prophet's house") whereas various hadith show otherwise, that it took him days to finally meet the Prophet (ﷺ) and, per one account in Sahih Muslim, even his inquiring about the whereabouts of the Prophet (ﷺ) ended in the Quraish beating him.

So I would try to find some further collaborating scholarly materials to first verify the claim from your book is accurate. (Note: the only example given by that source is Al Quraysh who were hostile to begin with; no other examples were given).

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.