2

In my answer to How often should we eat meat?, I quote two ahadith which I'm unsure about their reliability. The first is

Hazrat Ali Ibn Abi Talib, the cousin and son-in-law of Prophet Muhammad, the fourth Khalifa as per Sunni belief, has been quoted in Sharh Nahjul Balagha, as saying: “Do not make your stomach a graveyard of animals”.
dailypioneer.com

A variant of this hadith is found on what seems to be a Hare Krishna website:

Once the Holy Prophet Muhammad orders Hazrat Ali: “Don’t make your stomach a grave yard of innocent birds and animals.” From that day Hazrat Ali had faithfully followed this instruction.
harekrsna.de

I didn't find a reliable source for this hadith, nor was I able to determine its level of authenticity.

Question: What is the authenticity of this hadith?

(I asked about the other hadith here: What is the authenticity of the hadith "if you eat meat for 40 days, those qualities will come within you"?)

  • Please add "(pbuh)" or "(saw)" after our Prophet Mohammed (saw) . – user24306 Apr 4 '18 at 9:14
  • The relevant meta posts are: 1, 2, 3. This topic is not relevant to the question. – Rebecca J. Stones Apr 4 '18 at 9:19
  • Still I'm not convinced. I do think that you need to do it just so you show your gratitude among the Prophet. – user24306 Apr 4 '18 at 9:27
  • 1
    I so far only found it quoted as a statement of 'Ali in a commentary of nahj al-Balagha. Which would mean it is hard to qualify the authenticity. – Medi1Saif Apr 4 '18 at 9:28
  • @AnonymousI you are free to add it in your mind, but this discussion IMO is closed on islam SE. – Medi1Saif Apr 4 '18 at 9:29
3

The hadith that you quoted is not in any Sunni book that I have come across. Some have attributed this saying to Abū al-'Alā' al-Ma'arri but without citing references. An unattributed saying (potentially words of wisdom preserved through tradition over time) was documented by Muhammad al-Munawi in Fayd al-Qadīr:

وكبعض الحكماء حيث قال: يا أبناء الحكمة لا تجعلوا بطونكم قبورا للحيوان

NOTE: My own translation, so treat with care.

And as some wise men say: "O sons of wisdom, do not turn your stomachs into graveyards for animals."

Fayd al-Qadīr Sharh al-Jami' as-Saghīr 2/52

In Fasl al-Khitāb 2/526, Mohammad Nasr ad-Dīn Mohammad 'Uwaida attributed it to 'Ali ibn Abi Tālib, with almost identical wording, but again without citing a chain of narration or any other references.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.