Typically questions that revolve around "what should I do?" are closed as being of peer support nature, which this forum is not meant to accommodate. However, your question has a general rule in Islam.
The Prophet ﷺ laid out the criteria for selecting a wife:
عَنْ أَبِي هُرَيْرَةَ، عَنِ النَّبِيِّ صلى الله عليه وسلم قَالَ: تُنْكَحُ الْمَرْأَةُ لأَرْبَعٍ لِمَالِهَا وَلِحَسَبِهَا وَلِجَمَالِهَا وَلِدِينِهَا فَاظْفَرْ بِذَاتِ الدِّينِ تَرِبَتْ يَدَاكَ
Abu Huraira (Allah be pleased with him) reported Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) as saying: A woman may be married for four reasons: for her property, her status, her beauty and her religion, so try to get one who is religious, may your hand be besmeared with dust.
— Sahih Muslim, Book 17, Hadith 68
The phrase "your hand be besmeared with dust" (تربت يداك) refers to the hands touching the ground (hence the dust). It is an Arabic-language literary device that means wishing for a person to get rich.
This hadith is a form of prioritization for men in the criteria of selecting their future wife:
- Religion is the most important
- Wealth, family status, and beauty follow as a second priority.
This list does not mean completely abandoning what is a second priority but aims at putting things in their proper perspective as men tend to go for beauty over religion. Hence, my recommendation is:
- Carefully consider the pros and cons of each wife-to-be, and put more weight on the more religious one
- Pray istikhara (see Islam Q&A: How to pray istikhaarah and Islam Q&A: Praying istikhaarah is not contrary to be using one's intellect and examining matters to see which of two choices is better).