1

Women often talk about "non-mahram men", and I'm wondering if this is mostly tautological:

Question: For a woman, can another woman be a non-mahram?

I recognize there are people who are agender or have a non-binary gender, so presumably there are "non-mahram non-men", but I'm wondering if the term "non-mahram", when used by a woman, automatically excludes other women.

The Wikipedia page writes:

A mahram is an unmarriageable kin with whom marriage/sexual intercourse would be considered haram (illegal in Islam).

This seems to imply a woman is mahram to another woman. However, this also implies that underage boys are mahram, which contradicts a later sentence on the Wikipedia page: "Except for the spouse, being mahram is a permanent condition." This makes me Wikipedia's definition is not entirely accurate.

  • <comments deleted> Do not use comments for answering questions. If you have an answer to the question, post it as an answer. – goldPseudo Sep 23 '17 at 22:30
  • Wikipedia is not the best source for such matters (or any matter), it's a publicly open forum where anyone can contribute with their views - I would advice looking else where. – rac3b3nn0n Oct 10 '17 at 14:14
1

A 'mahram' in the marriage context , refers to being "permanently unmarriageable". so the husband's brother is not mahram to his brother's wife even-though the marriage between them is haram and invalid (because they are only conditionally unmarriageable ) . Also mahram refers to one of the men a woman should travel with and that she can be with without hijab , that's why here a woman is not considered mahram to another woman . So , the husband is mahram to his wife because she can travel with him alone and he can see her without hijab . that's why they said :

"Except for the spouse, being mahram is a permanent condition."

because of course if they got divorced he is no longer a mahram.

an underaged boy is not mahram , he is not "permanently unmarriageable" .

a mahram is used for men and women. For example, the daughter is mahram to her father , etc.

In travelling, a woman cannot be a mahram to anybody.

0

A mahram is someone you cannot marry, but that statement is only true for a legal marriage.

Since in Islam, marriage is only allowed between opposite sexes, and that have come to age (puberty), among other things that constitute a legal marriage, there is no need of reference to specify mahram between two woman (same sex) or towards minor (children).

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.