5

In Major Sins by Al-Dhahabi (pdf):

It was related that Jesus, the son of Mary (pbuh), passed by a flaming fire burning a man when he was in a journey. Then, Jesus carried some water to extinguish the fire. But, the fire turned into a boy and the man turned into fire. Surprisingly, Jesus said, "O Lord! May You return them back to life to ask them how they are? Allah then brought them to life. They were a man and a boy. Jesus asked them, "Who are you?" The man said, "O spirit of Allah, in the world I was afflicted by loving this boy and out of sexual excitement, I sodomized him. Later on when we died, we alternatively burned one another. This is our torture until the Day of Judgement."

I was surprised to read this as I don't recall reading anything else like it previously. I'm wondering if it's correct.

Question: Did Allah bring back to life a man and a boy who were burning each other after death?

The .pdf translation does not have a reference. Essentially, I'm asking for a reference for this (Qur'an, hadith, etc.). Where did this story come from? (Google keeps leading me back to Major Sins.)

  • this story was mentioned in a book of of ibn-hajar alhaithamy , it's a book about Major sins too ! alzwajr – Mustapha Elbazi Dec 9 '16 at 22:29
  • i don't know if this is accepted ! but this website could help .i always search about authenticity of ahadith in the arabic version of multaqa ahl alhadeth – Mustapha Elbazi Dec 9 '16 at 22:44
  • 1
    this could be some vision Jesus- pbuh- have gone through. as some people do. You can find some instances in spiritual-experiences.com. I mean it need not be that the man and the boy were raised alive a second time. – Itsme Dec 10 '16 at 3:47
2

This story is mentioned in an older version printed (not revised) and has a note from the revisor of the book (Mohyi Addin Misto) that it is not the real version from Imam Althahabi.

The revised version does not have this story and many other stories that do not have authentic sources, which does not match the style of Imam AlThahabi as he is known for his capability of differentiating the authentic from others.

I cannot at the moment search for English sources to prove what I mentioned but I will provide the Arabic ones anyway.

This is an Arabic article explains the point I mentioned that this version is not by Imam Althahabi.

And this is a scan of the revised version of the book it does not have this story.(page 201-208)

A second print does not have the story

So the answer is this story is not in Quran or Sunnah.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.