1

I have 85,000 dollars student loan debt, and also 3000 dollars in credit card debt. I am unemployed with some disabilities and older husband who is retired. Our only income is my husband's Social Security. I pay zakat on the gold jewellery I have. Are we required to pay zakat?

0

Based on the hanafi position, If you pay Zakah on Gold, then it would indicitae you are above the nisab, therefore you will not be eligible to recieve Zakat.

However Zakat is an indivudual obligation and can be received indivudualy.

You have Gold more than the nisab of the Gold standard so you can't receive the Zakat.

The Student Loan is most likely not due to be paid immediately, so you can't count this as a deduction, but if you are paying a monthly amount towards it, that can be deducted. The Credit Card depends on your intention of paying. If you pay only the minimum amount, then deduct that from your asset in that month. If you are looking to pay the full amount, then pay it all, and see what assets you have remaining. Even then, if you are below the nisab is cash assets, you still have Gold in excess, so you still won't meet Nisab.

Your husband is on Social Seciurity and probably has nothing left after expenses like bills, etc, so its possible that he is eligible. But you must consider any savings he has too. That is counted as an asset.

See sociable7.com/zakat

-1

Zakat is paid under certain conditions:

  • The person should be Muslim, adult, sane, free (not a slave).
  • They must posses a certain minimum amount of extra wealth (called nisab), fully owned by them in excess of personal use (such as clothing, food, shelter, household furniture, utensils, cars, etc).

  • They should have had this minimum amount in possession for a complete lunar year (hawl).

  • The wealth should be of a productive nature, from which they can derive profit or benefit such as merchandise for business, gold, silver, livestock, etc.
  • The minimum amount (or Nisab) should not be owed to someone, i.e., it should be free from debt.

so to answer your question, if the debt is too big that ones money(excluding the debt) doesn't reach the "Nisab" then one doesn't pay zakat.

I think having a job might as well be one of the requirements as not having a job is like not having a "productive nature".

If disability is a cause for you to not be able to gain money, then, wallah aalam(and God knows more), I don't think one should pay it, but in the case of someone that makes money even with a disability(say stephen hawking) then I think in that case zakat is a must.

Again old age preventing one to work, wallah aalah, is okay to not pay zakat but otherwise, I'm not so sure.

Remember that the zakat is paying 2.5% only! not more, not less!

  • 1
    Half of your answer is based on what you think and this is the part which is simply wrong. Having a job is no condition for Zakat nor being disabled one can give his money to another person to trade with it on ones behalf! – Medi1Saif Jun 6 '18 at 7:07
  • I am almost sure of what I'm saying, but I say "I think" so that if I said something wrong(I said without revising) people wouldn't take it a 100% for granted – Mohannad El-Nesr Jun 6 '18 at 17:03
  • Neither a not having job nor disability is a reason for not having to pay Zakat the two conditions are nisab and hawl no more nor less. Beside one must be able to feed himself after paying the zakat! Even a child or an insane person needs to pay zakat if these conditions are met (or more exactly his/her guardian needs to do that on his/her behalf) – Medi1Saif Jun 7 '18 at 8:07
  • an insane person shouldn't, someone who isn't asked to pray would be asked to pay zakat? other points I am not sure but you will have to support your points with evidence – Mohannad El-Nesr Jun 7 '18 at 17:16
  • 1
    This is the view of the majority of scholars as Allah says. "Take, [O, Muhammad], from their wealth a charity by which you purify them and cause them increase, and invoke [ Allah 's blessings] upon them 9:103" which is a general not exclusive order and you may refer to this fatwa – Medi1Saif Jun 8 '18 at 8:21

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.