2

A hackintosh computer is a standard personal computer that runs Apple Mac OS X as opposed to Windows or Linux. Hackintosh computers are a violation of the Apple EULA, as it states that "OS X shouldn't be installed on non-Apple-branded computers (Macintosh computers).

However, there are grounds to believe that this condition is only there to deter companies from making such computers and selling them for a profit (as in Psystar Inc. in the United States, later sued in court by Apple), not really to deter individuals.

My question is: Is the EULA valid?

Is the EULA enforceable in Islam? (like, does it apply if I remove it from the operating system?). It says that you automatically agree to its terms by merely using the operating system. Isn't that an enforced contract?

The condition of the non-Apple-branded computer seems to be a monopoly over the operating system (I sold the product to you BUT you can only use it however we wish and ONLY on our computers). Is such monopoly halal?

The company has R&D centers in Israel. Does that make any difference (supporting Zionists by using a product which may or may not be developed in Israel vs. harming somebody who supports Zionists by abusing their product?)

Edit: EULAs are not enforceable in my country. Please check yours for such enforceability.

  • 1
    Is that legal in the country where you are residing? – ozbek Jul 8 '16 at 1:00
  • Yeah, it is. I edited my post above. – Waseem Alkurdi Jul 8 '16 at 18:21
  • @Envayo 1. Fair enough. 2. a. That's logic, but that's if the terms are fair. Where's the fairness in FORCING somebody into a contract with unfair conditions? Moreover, have you got Islamic texts to back your claim? b. "Don't do something to others that you wouldn't want done to yourself" Does that make people "not do" stuff that you wouldn't want to be done to you? That makes moral sense, but not really applicable in real life with people. – Waseem Alkurdi Jul 9 '16 at 17:41
  • Really awesome! Well, nobody forces us to use Apple's operating systems, but Windows is expensive for many and no longer offers the bang-for-buck (it is a totally expensive, constant, and prolonged headache nowadays). One more point: As a contract, is it valid with a monopoly (احتكار)-type condition? – Waseem Alkurdi Jul 10 '16 at 11:22
  • 1
    Is Apple OK to allow home users like you to have a Hackingtosh? If not then you have got to ask yourself, Is stealing from someone Halal or Haram, even if you are stealing from an infidel? – Qaisar Khan Sep 6 '17 at 15:34
1

Once you purchase a product, it's halal for you to dispose of your possession as you see fit, and the seller cannot place a condition on how you will or won't use your possession. Therefore a contract that attempts to limit what you can and can't do with the product after you purchase it is not enforceable Islamically.

The only consideration would be the legality of it in the jurisdiction in which you live, but you've already stated EULAs are not valid in that jurisdiction.

|improve this answer|||||

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.