5

I try my best to do my prayers on time and would not miss any. Recently, i watched a youtube video by one of the Islamic lecturer from Saudi Arabia , quoting a hadith which i do not have knowledge to authenticate that if someone is not praying or missed prayers becomes KAFER or in the exacted quoted Hadith by Assim Al Hakeem that Muhammad SAW said that the only difference between Muslim and Non-muslim is 5 time prayers. If a Muslim does not pray, then he or she is not Muslim.

Can you please shed light on this issue. As i have missed couple of my prayers, does it mean that this mistake of missing prayers expelled me from my religion of islam? or Assim Al Hakeem is quoted not authenticated hadith and his words are nothing but hoax?

7

I guess you refer to this hadith which is quoted in Sunan ibn Majah, Sunan an-Nasa-i, Jami' at-Tirmidhi, Musnad Ahmad and Mustadrak al-Hakim:

Narrated Abdullah bin Buraidah narrated from his father: that the Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) said: "The covenant between us and them is the Salat, so whoever abandons it he has committed disbelief." (Also narrted on the authority of ibn 'Abbas and Anas.

In his sharh (commentary) of Sunan an-Nasa-i Imam as-Suyuti said: this is a castigation for the one who doesn't pray and an alarming for him, which says you are nearer to become a kafir than being a Muslim or that you may end up as a non-Muslim if you don't repent and pray. He also added a quote of Al-Bayahqi saying something like this could also be taken literally as not praying could be considered as a disbelief which should be punished by taking his life as Imam Ahmad concluded from this hadith taking it literally.

I remember that there was a discussion between Imam a-Shafi'i and Imam Ahmad on the matter where Imam a-Shafi'i could clearly show a contradiction in the argumentation of Imam Ahmad.

There's also an other stronger hadith which you may find in almost all Sunan collections and in Sahih Muslim with slightly different wordings:

It is narrated on the authority of Abu Zubair that he heard Jabir b. 'Abdullah saying. I heard the Messenger of Allah (may peace and blessings be upon him) observing this: Between man and polytheism and unbelief is the abandonment of salat.

So the prevalent view of the Hanbali school is that, somebody who doesn't pray is kafir. This is the opinion of Imam Ahamad, Imam ibn al-Mubarak, Ishaq and some of the students of a-Shafi'i.

While Imam Malik, a-Shafi'i and some of his students say such a person is not kafir, but fasiq and he should be asked to repent, so if he/she repents and prays the matter is closed and it's up to Allah to punish or forgive him in the hereafter. But if he/she didn't repent and insisted in not to pray he should be punished by taking his life.

Imam abu Hanifa and some other Kufi scholars and al-Muzni (student of a-Shafi'i) said he is neither considered as kafir nor should the authorities take his life, but he should be jailed until he prays.

And here's a fatwa defending the view of Imam Ahamad and the salafis saying it is the only correct view.

You could also take a look in this thread (in Arabic) who deals with the matter.

And Allah knows best!

3

All Praise to Allah Subhanahu wa Taala and blessings of Him be on Prophet Muhammad peace be upon him His family and companions,

Indeed, I am Allah . There is no deity except Me, so worship Me and establish prayer for My remembrance.(Quran 20:14)

As the answer is given above I want to add in that interesting discussion between Imam Shafai Rahmatullah alayh and Imam Hanbal Rahmatullah alayh when Imam Shafai (Ra) asked Imam Hanbal (Ra) "That in your opinion if a person becomes kafir by not reading the Salah then how that person would be able to become a Muslim, On that Imam Hanbal(Ra) replied back that in order to become a Muslim he should Pray then Imam Shafai (Ra) replied "But the Prayer of the kafir is not considered as valid" ,On hearing that Imam Hanbal (Ra) was completely surprised."

Among hanafis if someone completely denies the Salah as part of the Islam(Obligation) then he would be out of fold of Islam (Kufr) other than that if it is due to laziness then he would be considered as religiously corrupt (Fisq).

See also this.

Allah swt and His Messenger knows best.

-1

Its not, to be a kafer you should make one thing regarding the missing prayer and its must important thing in Islam which is "Beliving that the paryer are not major work in Islam".

So you are Kafer when you belive in that!

One of my best resource in Arabic "تارك الصلاة"

  • This needs elaboration and doesn't really provide anything new to the given answers. – user23533 Jun 8 '18 at 9:36
  • I'm respecting your opinion @Yas – Atef Mohd Jun 9 '18 at 16:34

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.