11

I heard from an Ahmadi (sect) person that once the prophet went to a village. His followers told him there is a really pretty woman who lives here. The prophet contracted Mut'ah marriage with her for the night and left the next day. He said it was common in those days in Islam.

My question is: Did Prophet Muhammad (Peace be upon him) ever contract Muta'h (temporary) marriage? Is the above story true?

0
4

According to Shia Islam there is no proved evidence that show prophet himself did Mutah.

But please note when permission of an action is proved by Quran or authentic hadith there is no need for evidence that prophet or Ahl ul-Bayt practiced it and the evidence from Quran or Haith is enough to it be considered permitted.

There is a verse in Quran and many hadith in Shia Hadith books and some hadith in sunni Hadith books proving prophet permitted Mutah to sahaba and sahaba practiced Mutah. so there is enough proof for considering Mutah Halal even if no evidence is found prophet himself did or not.

References:

Temporary Marriage in Islamic Law

http://islamquest.net/fa/archive/question/4634 (you can use google translate to read.)

http://islamquest.net/fa/archive/question/915 (containing many evidence from sunni books)

4
  • it is interesting that the prophet had to do some of the things himself in order to allow it for others, as in the case of marrying his adopted son's wife. After that marriage, adoption was prohibited in Islam.
    – muslim1
    Sep 13 '12 at 11:21
  • 2
    Many people call Mutah a "virtuous deed" BUT unfortunately the prophet(pbuh) didnt get blessings from this virtuous deed?
    – islam101
    Sep 13 '12 at 12:08
  • 2
    @islam101 talk clear. I do not know who call it virtuous deed. the answer is clear. we have no historical evidence for it. but this does not mean he really did not. our history is from 1400 years ago. many history books burnt and destroyed in history. also mutah has terms and is for some special cases and not for lust of men. it is possible prophet did not have any need to use it. also verse of Quran is clear about Mutah. Sep 13 '12 at 13:42
  • @Ahmadi I am thinking the prophet definitely did it. We just do not have references for it (as of now).
    – muslim1
    Sep 13 '12 at 16:04
4

In both Shia and Sunni sources, there is no evidence that shows the prophet did practice the Muta'ah marriage when it was considered permissible to do so.

However, according to sunnis. The prophet prohibited the mutah marriage after wining the war of khebar. While according to shia sources, Muta'ah marriage is still permissible.

For more Information about Mutah marriage:

  1. Sunni:

  2. Shia: Why do Shi'as allow mut'ah marriage?

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .