3

On an online forum there is someone that keeps saying "I am Muhammad" as if he where impersonating the Prophet himself.

Is this ok? If so/not is there somewhere in the Qur'an that mentions it?

  • 2
    What if his name is Muhammad? – Daniel Jan 27 '15 at 23:31
  • 1
    Its not. He is saying these things in the context of this "Je suis Charlie" incident, replacing charlie with Muhammad. It just does not seem right to be ranting the name of the Prophet all over the place. – Mike Jan 27 '15 at 23:37
  • 2
    Everything before Allah is not the actions but the neeyath (intent) behind it.. If the person had an intent to impersonate prophet, then its a haraam / sin. We have no rights to judge nor the knowledge to understand the intent. Only the Almighty can.. – Mohammed Ashiq Jan 28 '15 at 0:56
  • @MohammedAshiq I said the same thing in a different answer. It is what is in your heart and Allah knows what is in your heart. What people believe your intentions are is the same as judging another - nobody should judge except Allah. – Dan Andrews Jan 28 '15 at 16:13
  • @dan yup.. I read that.. That's why I put my opinions in comment.. We don't need two answers conveying the same message. :-) – Mohammed Ashiq Jan 28 '15 at 16:18
2

Is the person is claiming to be the Prophet Mohamed, it is scientifically accurate to say he is lying, since we all know Prophet Mohamed PBUH is dead.

For lying, he is a sinner (liar and hypocrite) as we all know a sign of hypocrisy is lying.

1

Well I would agree with the most what has been said in the so far given Answers!

  • If somebody says "his Mohammad" and meaning he's the Prophet (May Allah honor him and grant him peace) he's at least lying, maybe a hypocrite.
  • if his intention is to say by this that he's a Prophet or a Messenger he even would be qualified as a disbeliever. As we know that Mohammad (peace be upon him) is/was the last Prophet from Qur'an and Sunna (for example in Sahih Muslim, Jami' at-Tirmdhi ., and Sahih al-Bukhari). and the Prophet (peace be upon him) himself told us that people will come and pretend to be a Messenger of Allah (see for example in Sahih al-Bukhari).

But on the other hand it's the intention that matters! So if he's neither pretending being a Prophet nor a Messenger and he's saying "I'm Mohammad" referring to the Messenger of Allah (May Allah honor him and grant him peace), but not meaning he really is Mohammad in person, then the matter -in my opinion- is according the circumstances and his real intention slightly or even totally different.

In your comment you said he replaced "Charlie" in "Je suis Charlie" by "Mohammad" so he's referring to the "caricature matter" at least in his opinion defending the Messenger of Allah (May Allah honor him and grant him peace). And that's a good cause, intention and deed. But I'm not in the position to judge as I don't know his intention, so maybe it would be regarded as a sin or as a good deed, but initially I would tend to the last one!

1

In Islam it is not allowed for anyone to impersonate any Prophet, be it a Nabi or a Rasool (Messenger). saying that "I am Muhammad" is not impersonation assuming the gentlemen's name is Muhammad. You will not find any prohibition in the Quraan directly to the above.

The closest meaning to the name "Muhammad" in English would be "one who is worthy of praise". so the poster could be saying "I am praiseworthy" or he could in fact be named Muhammad.

-1

As far as I searched, I found nothing related about it. Of course, it could be surveyed from some aspects such as:

Firstly in the case that @Daniel mentioned, if the meaning of the person is "my name is Muhammad", then it doesn't seem to be haram

Secondly in case that the meaning of the mentioned person is that I am prophet Mohammad, then it is completely haram and it is the duty of the related persons in charge (judicial) to arrest him and ...

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.