3

I went to a restaurant with my family today. And it's not a halal shop so ordered seafood and vegetarian dishes letting them we cannot have pork and they know about halal.

We ordered one dish with xo sauce and when I came home, found out from my sister that xo sauce normally always contains pork.

So, does having pork (or anything haram) unintentionally considered as a sin? If so, why and what should one do about it?

2

No, it's not a sin. You had the intention to not eat anything that's deemed haram and made sincere effort (by ordering vegetarian meal believe it contains nothing haram) to not do that. Therefore since it was not because of your carelessness that you had a meal that had a pork/haram ingredient in it, it's not a sin.

One of Ali's quotes:

Lo, verily intention is act itself.

So, your intention to not eat haram is considered as the act of not having it which in itself is a good deed. What was unintentionally had doesn't count.

2

A person who recognizes after eating food (or drink) that he/she has eaten a haram meal, in case there was no likelihood of the food (drink) being harām and there were signs indicating that it was halal, for instance, he/she had received the food from a Muslim person or restaurant, like a person has not committed a sin and he/she is not counted to be sinful. However, if the food had been doubtful such as when he or she received this food from a non-Muslim individual (or at a restaurant…), in which position, it is his/her duty to conduct an investigation to make sure that the food or drink is halal. This is not permissible to eat food unless one is sure that it is halal. In case there isn’t any sign indicating that the food or drink is halal or not, the general principle applicable to meat is that it is considered as harām and impure. Hence, one who intends to eat it must make sure that it is halal.

Imam Sadeq (a.s.) says about the destructive impacts of sins:

"The effect of this sin is that it deprives [the sinner] of worshipping. Sometimes, a man commits a sin at day time as a result of which he becomes deprived of staying awake and offering Night Prayers 1 except for when he repents after his iniquity and reforms (himself).”[2]

1 - Javadi Amoli, Abdullah, Stages of Morality in the Quran, pg.153.

[2] - Al-Maedah: 39

On the whole, I recommend you to read the reference below completely to be more informed regarding the issue.


Reference:

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.