2

Narrated Jabir: A man was buried along with my father and I did not like it till I took him (i.e. my father) out and buried him in a separate grave.

Sahih Buckari Book of Funerals number 435

Who's father this hadith talking about . Is it Allahs apostals or Narrator Jabir's ?

3

In the Arabic, there is no indication that Jabir is quoting anyone; the "my father" in this case is apparently referring to Jabir's father (i.e. the Ansar Abdullah ibn Amr ibn Haram) who died during the battle of Uhud.

There are other hadiths on the subject which provide more detail. One example (which is also narrated through Bukhari) is as follows:

Narrated Jabir: When the time of the Battle of Uhud approached, my father called me at night and said, "I think that I will be the first amongst the companions of the Prophet to be martyred. I do not leave anyone after me dearer to me than you, except Allah's Messenger's soul and I owe some debt and you should repay it and treat your sisters favorably (nicely and politely)." So in the morning he was the first to be martyred and was buried along with another (martyr). I did not like to leave him with the other (martyr) so I took him out of the grave after six months of his burial and he was in the same condition as he was on the day of burial, except a slight change near his ear.

Again, the Arabic doesn't indicate that he is quoting anybody, so there's no reason to believe that this is referring to anybody but Jabir's own father, and especially not the father of the prophet who by the time of Uhud had been dead for over fifty years.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.