4

It is okay to say یا رسول الله.

The word "یا" means "O" which only can be used if somebody is in front of you. If I say "یا الله" then it is okay because Allah is everywhere so I can say this but should I say "یا رسول الله" because our Prophet Muhammad (SAW) is not in front of us.

I am asking this question because their are two mosques in my area and in both mosques "یا رسول الله" is written along with "یا الله" so one of my cousin refuse to offer pray in these mosques because he "my cousin" said "my prayer won't be accepted if I offer my prayer in these mosques".

  • 1
    Prophet's soul is still in existence and He hears us and sees us. So we can use Prophet as means of seeking nearness to Allah. This is called Tawasoul. But your friend must be a follower of salafist or wahhabi school as these schools consider calling Prophet for help and support as tantamount to shirk! – infatuated Aug 10 '14 at 6:23
  • Yes they think. – Murtaza Aug 10 '14 at 7:47
  • Q&A of Tawasoul you mentioned is completely going other direction. I want to take it generally. Let make it clear, can you provide reference from Ayah or Hadith that Tawasoul is right. – Murtaza Aug 10 '14 at 8:05
  • Also in that Q&A, the OP asking question and used Tawassol with recourse so tell why recourse with tawassol. Both words have different meaning. – Murtaza Aug 10 '14 at 8:18
1

We beleive that prophet muhammed passed away so we cannot address him anymore. We should try and preach this in mosque such as yours. I am not sure about praying there because your cousin has a point but i think i would pray in such a mosque if time is running out and there are no other options

| improve this answer | |
  • Please back up your answer by citing Islamic sources. Not all schools of jurisprudence consider calling on Prophet for support haram. – infatuated Aug 10 '14 at 6:25
  • I am not asking either I can pray in that mosque or not. I am asking, is it right to call یا رسول الله? – Murtaza Aug 10 '14 at 8:04
  • No, you cannot. He passed away. "Ya" is used for people who are alive. We do not believe that he is alive because in the quran it is clearly mentioned in Ayat ul qursi that only Allah Almighty can live forever. In surah rahman Ayah 26 it is mentioned again that every Makhlooq on the planet is suppose to end – Saad Aug 14 '14 at 4:05
-2

when we pass from grave yard or enter the graveyard we have to say "as-salam-o-alaikum-ya-aehlal-quboor" there is no shirk or such haram thing in that then way so in saying "ya-rasul-allah"

| improve this answer | |

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.