Skip to main content
Islam

Return to Answer

Improved formatting - also removed your mention of the moderator , Your answer shouldn't take a conversational tone , because that isn't its purpose , you would be better answering in the comments.
Source Link
edit approved Sep 10, 2018 at 8:38
SongBird
edit approved Sep 10, 2018 at 8:38
SongBird
  • 448
  • 2
  • 10

@goldPseudo bro. i've answered his question not yours. His question is saying about Ahle-Kitab so if we know who are ahle-kitab then the question is solved!.... QuestionQuestion asked in about O you who have believed, decreed upon you is fasting as it was decreed upon those before you that you may become righteous - (2:183) here

O you who have believed, decreed upon you is fasting as it was decreed upon those before you that you may become righteous - (2:183)

Here it is written " O you who have believed " - believing people were not present before 1400 years ago? People who followed Moses(AS) and Ibrahim(AS) were also Believing people. This ayat is for believing people of all times not just people from 1400 years ago til now.

https://quran.com/6/83-89 - ( 
Read all ayats from 83 til 89 , Allah mentions all Prophets here and then Allah says "Those are the ones to whom We gave alkitab and authority and prophethood") (so so for 18 Prophets Allah gave al-kitab that is One Book, same Book that is in quran.com/2/2 https://quran.com/2/2 - in above ayat al-kitab is mentioned singular so singular same book for multiple prophets, plural of al-kitab is kutub).

We are the ahle-Kitab - we have al-kitab i.e Quran so all prophets who got this same al-kitab and people who are with prophets are ahle-kitab so they all kept same fasting like us nothing different.

Please watch this video itThis video also explains clearly same ayat mentioned in the question ----- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-Ss3peG_kYI&feature=youtu.be&t=267

Hope you have no confusion in understanding the video and above ayats. JazakAllah.

@goldPseudo bro. i've answered his question not yours. His question is saying about Ahle-Kitab so if we know who are ahle-kitab then the question is solved!.... Question asked in about O you who have believed, decreed upon you is fasting as it was decreed upon those before you that you may become righteous - (2:183) here it is written " O you who have believed " - believing people were not present before 1400 years ago? People who followed Moses(AS) and Ibrahim(AS) were also Believing people. This ayat is for believing people of all times not just people from 1400 years ago til now.

https://quran.com/6/83-89 - (Read all ayats from 83 til 89 Allah mentions all Prophets here and then Allah says "Those are the ones to whom We gave alkitab and authority and prophethood") (so for 18 Prophets Allah gave al-kitab that is One Book, same Book that is in quran.com/2/2 - in above ayat al-kitab is mentioned singular so singular same book for multiple prophets, plural of al-kitab is kutub)

We are the ahle-Kitab - we have al-kitab i.e Quran so all prophets who got this same al-kitab and people who are with prophets are ahle-kitab so they all kept same fasting like us nothing different.

Please watch this video it explains clearly same ayat mentioned in the question ----- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-Ss3peG_kYI&feature=youtu.be&t=267

Hope you have no confusion in understanding the video and above ayats. JazakAllah.

Question asked in about

O you who have believed, decreed upon you is fasting as it was decreed upon those before you that you may become righteous - (2:183)

Here it is written " O you who have believed " - believing people were not present before 1400 years ago? People who followed Moses(AS) and Ibrahim(AS) were also Believing people. This ayat is for believing people of all times not just people from 1400 years ago til now.

https://quran.com/6/83-89 
Read all ayats from 83 til 89 , Allah mentions all Prophets here and then Allah says "Those are the ones to whom We gave alkitab and authority and prophethood" so for 18 Prophets Allah gave al-kitab that is One Book, same Book that is in https://quran.com/2/2 - in above ayat al-kitab is mentioned singular so singular same book for multiple prophets, plural of al-kitab is kutub.

We are the ahle-Kitab - we have al-kitab i.e Quran so all prophets who got this same al-kitab and people who are with prophets are ahle-kitab so they all kept same fasting like us nothing different.

This video also explains clearly same ayat mentioned in the question

Hope you have no confusion in understanding the video and above ayats. JazakAllah.

Source Link
ikram0459
ikram0459
  • 13
  • 6

@goldPseudo bro. i've answered his question not yours. His question is saying about Ahle-Kitab so if we know who are ahle-kitab then the question is solved!.... Question asked in about O you who have believed, decreed upon you is fasting as it was decreed upon those before you that you may become righteous - (2:183) here it is written " O you who have believed " - believing people were not present before 1400 years ago? People who followed Moses(AS) and Ibrahim(AS) were also Believing people. This ayat is for believing people of all times not just people from 1400 years ago til now.

https://quran.com/6/83-89 - (Read all ayats from 83 til 89 Allah mentions all Prophets here and then Allah says "Those are the ones to whom We gave alkitab and authority and prophethood") (so for 18 Prophets Allah gave al-kitab that is One Book, same Book that is in quran.com/2/2 - in above ayat al-kitab is mentioned singular so singular same book for multiple prophets, plural of al-kitab is kutub)

We are the ahle-Kitab - we have al-kitab i.e Quran so all prophets who got this same al-kitab and people who are with prophets are ahle-kitab so they all kept same fasting like us nothing different.

Please watch this video it explains clearly same ayat mentioned in the question ----- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-Ss3peG_kYI&feature=youtu.be&t=267

Hope you have no confusion in understanding the video and above ayats. JazakAllah.