Skip to main content
edited body
Source Link
Medi1Saif
  • 46.1k
  • 13
  • 84
  • 209

Ibn al-HajjHaaj al-Fasy (maliki) said in his al-Madkhal المدخل (My own translation take it carefully):

Ibn al-Hajj al-Fasy (maliki) said in his al-Madkhal المدخل (My own translation take it carefully):

Ibn al-Haaj al-Fasy (maliki) said in his al-Madkhal المدخل (My own translation take it carefully):

deleted 56 characters in body
Source Link
Medi1Saif
  • 46.1k
  • 13
  • 84
  • 209

First of all who told you that you should read tasbih after the 4th raka' of Taraweeh?

I was astonished that I've never heard about this until reading your post!

Any act in Islam needs a clear backup, but in this case scholars have three different opinions on thisthe matter some said it is permissibleit is permissible other notnot and others even said it is bida'hit is bida'h among those who said it is permissible you may find scholars like al-Kassani in his book Badai' as-Sanai' بدائع الصنائع from the hanafi school of fiqh and al-Mirdawi -Hanbali scholar- in his al-Insaf الإنصاف . Here the statement of al-Kassani (My own translation take it carefully):

Ibn al-Humam (Hanafi) in his Fath al-Qadir فتح القدير only confirms the sitting or pausing between two sets of taraweeh as a custom of the people of the two harams (Mekka and Medina). So what people have done in between was up to them and that they make tasbeeh etc. is a possible option. He also made clear that people of Medina used to pray during this 4 optional raka'a's.

First of all who told you that you should read tasbih after the 4th raka' of Taraweeh?

I was astonished that I've never heard about this until reading your post!

Any act in Islam needs a clear backup but scholars have three different opinions on this some said it is permissible other not and others even said it is bida'h among those who said it is permissible you may find scholars like al-Kassani in his book Badai' as-Sanai' بدائع الصنائع from the hanafi school of fiqh and al-Mirdawi -Hanbali scholar- in his al-Insaf الإنصاف . Here the statement of al-Kassani (My own translation take it carefully):

Ibn al-Humam (Hanafi) in his Fath al-Qadir فتح القدير only confirms the sitting or pausing between two sets of taraweeh as a custom of the people of the two harams (Mekka and Medina). So what people have done in between was up to them and that they make tasbeeh etc. is possible option. He also made clear that people of Medina used to pray during this 4 optional raka'a's.

I was astonished that I've never heard about this until reading your post!

Any act in Islam needs a clear backup, but in this case scholars have three different opinions on the matter some said it is permissible other not and others even said it is bida'h among those who said it is permissible you may find scholars like al-Kassani in his book Badai' as-Sanai' بدائع الصنائع from the hanafi school of fiqh and al-Mirdawi -Hanbali scholar- in his al-Insaf الإنصاف . Here the statement of al-Kassani (My own translation take it carefully):

Ibn al-Humam (Hanafi) in his Fath al-Qadir فتح القدير only confirms the sitting or pausing between two sets of taraweeh as a custom of the people of the two harams (Mekka and Medina). So what people have done in between was up to them and that they make tasbeeh etc. is a possible option. He also made clear that people of Medina used to pray during this 4 optional raka'a's.

added 97 characters in body
Source Link
Medi1Saif
  • 46.1k
  • 13
  • 84
  • 209

وأما الاستراحة بعد خمس تسليمات فهل يستحب ؟ قال بعضهم : نعم ، وقال بعضهمIbn al-Humam : لا يستحب وهو الصحيح ; لأنه خلاف عمل السلف والله الموفق(Hanafi) in his Fath al-Qadir .
There'sفتح القدير only confirms the sitting or pausing between two sets of taraweeh as a dispute whethercustom of the pause afterpeople of the fifth taseleem (tarweehah) is mustahabtwo harams (recommended)? Some said yes others said it is not recommendedMekka and this is the correct view as this is in opposition toMedina). So what our Sakafpeople have done in between was up to them and Allahthat they make tasbeeh etc. is the bringerpossible option. He also made clear that people of successMedina used to pray during this 4 optional raka'a's.

وأما الاستراحة بعد خمس تسليمات فهل يستحب ؟ قال بعضهم : نعم ، وقال بعضهم : لا يستحب وهو الصحيح ; لأنه خلاف عمل السلف والله الموفق .
There's a dispute whether the pause after the fifth taseleem (tarweehah) is mustahab (recommended)? Some said yes others said it is not recommended and this is the correct view as this is in opposition to what our Sakaf have done and Allah is the bringer of success.

Ibn al-Humam (Hanafi) in his Fath al-Qadir فتح القدير only confirms the sitting or pausing between two sets of taraweeh as a custom of the people of the two harams (Mekka and Medina). So what people have done in between was up to them and that they make tasbeeh etc. is possible option. He also made clear that people of Medina used to pray during this 4 optional raka'a's.

added 385 characters in body
Source Link
Medi1Saif
  • 46.1k
  • 13
  • 84
  • 209
Loading
Source Link
Medi1Saif
  • 46.1k
  • 13
  • 84
  • 209
Loading