Many years ago, I was living in a Islamic country and I was student of Islamic religion, because I wanted to be a Muslim by heart and by knowledge  , I did not want to be inherited Muslim because my father was Muslim and I must follow him. I am now living in a non Islamic country and so far, on any guidance of Quran and Hadith  , I researched and found the logic and the secret behind every commandment of haram and halal. One thing that really bothers me and I could not find any answer is that stoning sculpture of Satan during Haj Pilgrimage, what is the logic behind stoning satan? It is just a sculpture. I see people stoning it. it somehow does not make any sense for me.

I do not know whether stoning satan is farz or sunnah or why it should be done. What could Muslim benefit from it. I would be grateful if you could elaborate on the logic and basis of this stoning practice.

Someone told me that this practice is just for the indoctrinating purposes. Same way like for dry ablution when there is no water, at least you do something so that you indoctrinate your self that at least you did something than nothing to became clean and do your pray. I get the point on the dry ablution but my brain does not work on the stoning of Satan

Many years ago, I was living in a Islamic country and I was student of Islamic religion, because I wanted to be a Muslim by heart and by knowledge, I did not want to be inherited Muslim because my father was Muslim and I must follow him. I am now living in a non-Islamic country and so far, using the guidance of Quran and Hadith, I researched and found the logic behind every commandment of haram and halal. One thing that really bothers me and I could not find any answer is that stoning sculpture of Satan during Hajj Pilgrimage. It is just a sculpture. I see people stoning it. It somehow does not make any sense for me.

What is the logic behind stoning satan?

I do not know whether stoning satan is farz or sunnah or why it should be done. What could Muslim benefit from it. I would be grateful if you could elaborate on the logic and basis of this stoning practice.

Someone told me that this practice is just for the indoctrinating purposes. Same way like for dry ablution when there is no water, at least you do something so that you indoctrinate your self that at least you did something than nothing to became clean and do your pray. I get the point on the dry ablution but my brain does not work on the stoning of Satan

Many years ago, I was living in a Islamic country and I was student of Islamic religion, because I wanted to be a muslim by heart and by knowledge , I did not want to be inherited muslim because my father was muslim and I must follow him. I am now living in a non Islamic country and so far, on any guidance of Quran and Hadith , I researched and found logics and the secret behind every commandment of Harram and Halal. one thing that really bothers me and I could not find any answer is that Stoning sculpture of Satan during Haj Pilgrimage, what is the logic behind stoning satan. it is just a sculpture. I see people stoning it. it somehow does not make any sense for me. I do not know whether stoning satan is Farz or Sunnah or why it should be done. what could muslim benefit from it. I would be grateful if you could elaborate on the logic and basis of this stoning practice. someone told me that this practice is just for the indoctrinating purposes. same way like for dry ablution when there is no water, at least you do something so that you indoctrinate your self that at least you did something than nothing to became clean and do your pray. I get the point on the dry ablution but my brain does not work on the stoning of Satan

Many years ago, I was living in a Islamic country and I was student of Islamic religion, because I wanted to be a Muslim by heart and by knowledge , I did not want to be inherited Muslim because my father was Muslim and I must follow him. I am now living in a non Islamic country and so far, on any guidance of Quran and Hadith , I researched and found the logic and the secret behind every commandment of haram and halal. One thing that really bothers me and I could not find any answer is that stoning sculpture of Satan during Haj Pilgrimage, what is the logic behind stoning satan? It is just a sculpture. I see people stoning it. it somehow does not make any sense for me. 

I do not know whether stoning satan is farz or sunnah or why it should be done. What could Muslim benefit from it. I would be grateful if you could elaborate on the logic and basis of this stoning practice.

Someone told me that this practice is just for the indoctrinating purposes. Same way like for dry ablution when there is no water, at least you do something so that you indoctrinate your self that at least you did something than nothing to became clean and do your pray. I get the point on the dry ablution but my brain does not work on the stoning of Satan