Skip to main content
Notice removed Authoritative reference needed by oshirowanen
Bounty Ended with user9301's answer chosen by oshirowanen
deleted 736 characters in body
Source Link
oshirowanen
  • 2.4k
  • 6
  • 35
  • 61

And those who accuse chaste women and then do not produce four witnesses - lash them with eighty lashes and do not accept from them testimony ever after. And those are the defiantly disobedient, Quran.com/24/4

Via that verse, it seems that the punishment for accusing a chaste woman of fornication or adultery without witnesses is 80 lashes. I assume it's the same punishment in the following senarios:

  1. If a man accuses a chaste woman of fornication/adultery without witnesses
  2. If a woman accuses a chaste man of fornication/adultery without witnesses
  3. If a man accuses a chaste man of fornication/adultery without witnesses
  4. If a woman accuses a chaste woman of fornication/adultery without witnesses

My question is, as bad as fornication/adultery areis, they areit's no where near as bad as rape. So, what is the punishment if:

  1. A man accuses a woman of raping someone without any proof (even if the doctors say that there is no such evidence)
  2. A woman accuses a man of raping someone without any proof (even if the doctors say that there is no such evidence)
  3. A manSomeone accuses a man of raping someone without any proof (even if the doctors say that there is no such evidence)
  4. A woman accuses a woman of raping someone without any proof (even if the doctors say that there is no such evidence)

Sunni > Hanafi views please.

And those who accuse chaste women and then do not produce four witnesses - lash them with eighty lashes and do not accept from them testimony ever after. And those are the defiantly disobedient, Quran.com/24/4

Via that verse, it seems that the punishment for accusing a chaste woman of fornication or adultery without witnesses is 80 lashes. I assume it's the same punishment in the following senarios:

  1. If a man accuses a chaste woman of fornication/adultery without witnesses
  2. If a woman accuses a chaste man of fornication/adultery without witnesses
  3. If a man accuses a chaste man of fornication/adultery without witnesses
  4. If a woman accuses a chaste woman of fornication/adultery without witnesses

My question is, as bad as fornication/adultery are, they are no where near as bad as rape. So, what is the punishment if:

  1. A man accuses a woman of raping someone without any proof (even if the doctors say that there is no such evidence)
  2. A woman accuses a man of raping someone without any proof (even if the doctors say that there is no such evidence)
  3. A man accuses a man of raping someone without any proof (even if the doctors say that there is no such evidence)
  4. A woman accuses a woman of raping someone without any proof (even if the doctors say that there is no such evidence)

Sunni > Hanafi views please.

And those who accuse chaste women and then do not produce four witnesses - lash them with eighty lashes and do not accept from them testimony ever after. And those are the defiantly disobedient, Quran.com/24/4

Via that verse, it seems that the punishment for accusing a chaste woman of fornication or adultery without witnesses is 80 lashes.

My question is, as bad as fornication/adultery is, it's no where near as bad as rape. So, what is the punishment if:

  1. Someone accuses a man of raping someone without any proof (even if the doctors say that there is no such evidence)

Sunni > Hanafi views please.

added 36 characters in body
Source Link
oshirowanen
  • 2.4k
  • 6
  • 35
  • 61

And those who accuse chaste women and then do not produce four witnesses - lash them with eighty lashes and do not accept from them testimony ever after. And those are the defiantly disobedient, Quran.com/24/4

Via that verse, it seems that the punishment for accusing a chaste woman of fornication or adultery without witnesses is 80 lashes. I assume it's the same punishment in the following senarios:

  1. If a man accuses a chaste woman of fornication/adultery without witnesses
  2. If a woman accuses a chaste man of fornication/adultery without witnesses
  3. If a man accuses a chaste man of fornication/adultery without witnesses
  4. If a woman accuses a chaste woman of fornication/adultery without witnesses

My question is, as bad as fornication/adultery are, they are no where near as bad as rape. So, what is the punishment if:

  1. A man accuses a woman of raping someone without any proof (even if the doctors say that there is no such evidence)
  2. A woman accuses a man of raping someone without any proof (even if the doctors say that there is no such evidence)
  3. A man accuses a man of raping someone without any proof (even if the doctors say that there is no such evidence)
  4. A woman accuses a woman of raping someone without any proof (even if the doctors say that there is no such evidence)

Sunni > Hanafi views please.

And those who accuse chaste women and then do not produce four witnesses - lash them with eighty lashes and do not accept from them testimony ever after. And those are the defiantly disobedient, Quran.com/24/4

Via that verse, it seems that the punishment for accusing a chaste woman of fornication or adultery without witnesses is 80 lashes. I assume it's the same punishment in the following senarios:

  1. If a man accuses a chaste woman of fornication/adultery without witnesses
  2. If a woman accuses a chaste man of fornication/adultery without witnesses
  3. If a man accuses a chaste man of fornication/adultery without witnesses
  4. If a woman accuses a chaste woman of fornication/adultery without witnesses

My question is, as bad as fornication/adultery are, they are no where near as bad as rape. So, what is the punishment if:

  1. A man accuses a woman of raping someone without any proof (even if the doctors say that there is no such evidence)
  2. A woman accuses a man of raping someone without any proof (even if the doctors say that there is no such evidence)
  3. A man accuses a man of raping someone without any proof (even if the doctors say that there is no such evidence)
  4. A woman accuses a woman of raping someone without any proof (even if the doctors say that there is no such evidence)

And those who accuse chaste women and then do not produce four witnesses - lash them with eighty lashes and do not accept from them testimony ever after. And those are the defiantly disobedient, Quran.com/24/4

Via that verse, it seems that the punishment for accusing a chaste woman of fornication or adultery without witnesses is 80 lashes. I assume it's the same punishment in the following senarios:

  1. If a man accuses a chaste woman of fornication/adultery without witnesses
  2. If a woman accuses a chaste man of fornication/adultery without witnesses
  3. If a man accuses a chaste man of fornication/adultery without witnesses
  4. If a woman accuses a chaste woman of fornication/adultery without witnesses

My question is, as bad as fornication/adultery are, they are no where near as bad as rape. So, what is the punishment if:

  1. A man accuses a woman of raping someone without any proof (even if the doctors say that there is no such evidence)
  2. A woman accuses a man of raping someone without any proof (even if the doctors say that there is no such evidence)
  3. A man accuses a man of raping someone without any proof (even if the doctors say that there is no such evidence)
  4. A woman accuses a woman of raping someone without any proof (even if the doctors say that there is no such evidence)

Sunni > Hanafi views please.

Notice added Authoritative reference needed by oshirowanen
Bounty Started worth 500 reputation by oshirowanen
Tweeted twitter.com/#!/StackIslam/status/547038070366015488
Source Link
oshirowanen
  • 2.4k
  • 6
  • 35
  • 61

Accusing a person of rape?

And those who accuse chaste women and then do not produce four witnesses - lash them with eighty lashes and do not accept from them testimony ever after. And those are the defiantly disobedient, Quran.com/24/4

Via that verse, it seems that the punishment for accusing a chaste woman of fornication or adultery without witnesses is 80 lashes. I assume it's the same punishment in the following senarios:

  1. If a man accuses a chaste woman of fornication/adultery without witnesses
  2. If a woman accuses a chaste man of fornication/adultery without witnesses
  3. If a man accuses a chaste man of fornication/adultery without witnesses
  4. If a woman accuses a chaste woman of fornication/adultery without witnesses

My question is, as bad as fornication/adultery are, they are no where near as bad as rape. So, what is the punishment if:

  1. A man accuses a woman of raping someone without any proof (even if the doctors say that there is no such evidence)
  2. A woman accuses a man of raping someone without any proof (even if the doctors say that there is no such evidence)
  3. A man accuses a man of raping someone without any proof (even if the doctors say that there is no such evidence)
  4. A woman accuses a woman of raping someone without any proof (even if the doctors say that there is no such evidence)