Skip to main content
Islam

Return to Answer

formating and language improved. cruft removed.
Source Link
edit approved Dec 29, 2013 at 20:44
Bleeding Fingers
edit approved Dec 29, 2013 at 20:44
Bleeding Fingers
  • 3.2k
  • 7
  • 34
  • 59

Brother/sister, YourYour extraction about Cake is Haramcake being haram is only an assumption. For having any thinganything to be haram there should be a clear order from Allah or Prophet PBUH(PBUH). For example

E.g.: if aI spare a food for my son, Ali, then iI will say that this is Ali's food, so iI am attaching name with food. But if iI eat Ali's food then is it haram for me? So always ask from expert and Allah fearing scholars, short knowledge people start to promote invalid logic and wrong extraction from islam.

Brother/sister, Your extraction about Cake is Haram is only assumption. For having any thing haram there should be a clear order from Allah or Prophet PBUH. For example if a spare a food for my son then i will say that this is Ali's food, so i am attaching name with food. But if i eat Ali's food then is it haram for me? So always ask from expert and Allah fearing scholars, short knowledge people start to promote invalid logic and wrong extraction from islam.

Your extraction about cake being haram is only an assumption. For anything to be haram there should be a clear order from Allah or Prophet(PBUH).

E.g.: if I spare food for my son, Ali, then I will say that this is Ali's food, so I am attaching name with food. But if I eat Ali's food then is it haram for me?

Source Link
Imran
Imran
  • 1

Brother/sister, Your extraction about Cake is Haram is only assumption. For having any thing haram there should be a clear order from Allah or Prophet PBUH. For example if a spare a food for my son then i will say that this is Ali's food, so i am attaching name with food. But if i eat Ali's food then is it haram for me? So always ask from expert and Allah fearing scholars, short knowledge people start to promote invalid logic and wrong extraction from islam.